äÄöÖüÜß

Lautschrift

Deutsch
Monophthonge
ɛɪɔɶøʏ
Diphthonge
au̯ai̯ɔʏ̯
Konsonantensystem
çʤŋʃʀʁʒ
Englisch
Monophthonge
ɛɜɪɔʊəɑɐɒæ
Konsonantensystem
ŋθʃʒçʍɹɻɫɾ
Diakritische Zeichen
ˈː
 
leo-ende

Topicwho /which with animals
Comment
Hallo,

verwendet man bei Tieren who/which in Relativsätzen.

Bsp.

This is a monkey who/which carries a deadly virus.
Tinka, my cat, who/sleeps all day long is....

Danke und Gruß
zejoo
Author Zejo (411149) 04 Mai 13, 09:10
Comment
Hallo,

zunächst mal verwendet man am Ende von Fragesätzen logischerweise ein sogenanntes Fragezeichen.

Ansonsten zu deinen Beispielen (aus meiner Sicht als Non-native Speaker):

- a monkey which ...

- Tinka, my cat, who ...
(Was soll hier der Schrägstrich zwischen "who" und "sleeps"?
#1Author Woody 1 (455616) 04 Mai 13, 09:38
Comment
In my AE usage, the more I have anthropomorphized the animal, the more likely I am to use "who" instead of "which." Pets tend to be highly anthropomorphized, so they are typically "who." Wild animals are not, hence they are typically "which."

This rule also applies to my daughter's stuffed animals.
#2Author Sharper (238296) 04 Mai 13, 12:35
Comment
(Was soll hier der Schrägstrich zwischen "who" und "sleeps"? - da ist sicherlich das "which" rausgefallen ... who/which sleeps all day long is


mE : Tiere generell : which
(Haus-)Tiere mit einem Namen : who ist möglich
#3Author no me bré (700807) 04 Mai 13, 13:06
Comment
The basic rule is that we use "who" for people, "which" for animals and things, and "that" for people/animals/things.

But people use words in the way they want, and it's not uncommon for people to use "who" for animals, particularly when they're emphasizing their personality.

I can't think of the opposite case: the man which. It was used in the past, for example, in the King James Bible (1611). https://www.google.com/search?q=%22the+man+which%22&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8&aq=t&rls=o...

But no longer.
#4Author eric (new york) (63613) 04 Mai 13, 15:51
Comment
I can't think of the opposite case: the man which

Hmm ... vielleicht, wenn Außerirdische in einem Science-Fiction-Roman das Verhalten der Erdbewohner studieren?
"The man which had been promised the bottle of beer worked 2.71 times harder than the others."
;-)
#5Author erasmus (723849) 04 Mai 13, 20:00
Comment
Even where "who" is not used, the genitive "whose" is often possible, and the defining "that" is also used for people.
#6Author MikeE (236602) 04 Mai 13, 21:29
  Only registered users are allowed to post in this forum