Werbung - LEO ohne Werbung? LEO Pur
LEO

Sie scheinen einen AdBlocker zu verwenden.

Wollen Sie LEO unterstützen?

Dann deaktivieren Sie AdBlock für LEO, spenden Sie oder nutzen Sie LEO Pur!

 
  •  
  • Übersicht

    Sprachlabor

    Komma nach "In the morning" "In the evening" "In the afternoon" am Satzanfang erforderlich?

    Betrifft

    Komma nach "In the morning" "In the evening" "In the afternoon" am Satzanfang erforderlich?

    Kommentar
    Beispiel: In the morning, I walked the dog. vs. In the morning I walked the dog.

    Muss in dem Beispiel ein Komma gesetzt werden?

    Falls es nicht zwingend erforderlich ist, hat es eine Auswirkung auf die Satzbedeutung? Steht die Zeitangabe durch ein Komma mehr im Vordergrund?
    Verfasserprojo12 (899245) 07 Nov. 14, 10:54
    Kommentar
    No comma.

    If a comma were used, I would not understand its purpose.
    #1VerfasserHappyWarrior (964133) 07 Nov. 14, 10:56
    Kommentar
    I would use one because "in the morning" is functioning as an introductory prepositional phrase. That's what my senior-year English teacher from hell drilled into us. However, I'm in the minority nowadays, and the Purdue writing lab (below) gives some practical advice. Unfortunately, most people omit the comma after even very long introductory phrases.


    From https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/6...
    When to use a comma

    Introductory elements often require a comma, but not always. Use a comma in the following cases:

    After an introductory clause.
    After a long introductory prepositional phrase or more than one introductory prepositional phrase.
    After introductory verbal phrases, some appositive phrases, or absolute phrases.
    If there is a distinct pause.
    To avoid confusion.

    When not to use a comma

    Some introductory elements don't require a comma, and sometimes the subject of a sentence looks like an introductory element but isn't. Do not use a comma in the following cases:

    After a brief prepositional phrase. (Is it a single phrase of fewer than five words?)
    After a restrictive (essential) appositive phrase. (See our document on appositives.)
    To separate the subject from the predicate. (See below.)
    #2Verfasser hbberlin (420040) 07 Nov. 14, 11:08
    Kommentar
    Comma optional.

    hat es eine Auswirkung auf die Satzbedeutung?

    No, but maybe in the case of longer phrases on its understandability, see hbberlin's answer.
    #3Verfasser amw (532814) 07 Nov. 14, 11:15
    Kommentar
    Also agree; one can/needs to be pragmatic when setting commas in English I'd say.
    #4Verfassermikefm (760309) 07 Nov. 14, 12:15
    Kommentar
    Thanks for your answers! I think I’ll handle it like hbberlin recommends with his citation. As “In the morning” is a short introductory prepositional phrase of fewer than five words, I won’t use a comma. Keeps it easy ;-)
    #5Verfasserprojo12 (899245) 07 Nov. 14, 21:26
    Kommentar
    Unfortunately, that "fewer-than-five-words" rule doesn't always apply. Having said that, I'd like to point out that hbberlin even indicates as much.
    #6Verfasser dude (253248) 07 Nov. 14, 21:43
    Kommentar
    I'd use a comma, too :-)
    #7Verfasser Carly-AE (237428) 07 Nov. 14, 23:46
     
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  
 
 
 
 
 ­ automatisch zu ­ ­ umgewandelt