Advertising - LEO without ads? LEO Pur
LEO

It looks like you’re using an ad blocker.

Would you like to support LEO?

Disable your ad blocker for LEO or make a donation.

 
  •  
  • Forum home

    Language lab

    "How do they compare?" <- is this correct?

    Topic

    "How do they compare?" <- is this correct?

    Comment
    I'm writing a manuscript for a scientific publication and english is not my mother tongue, so I'll need to ask a question.

    The title I was thinking of is this one :
    " 'Group 1' – How Do They Compare? A Comprehensive Cohort Analysis Comparing Growth and Therapy Response to 'Group 2' " (I changed the real group name to "group name 1/2")

    The part "how do they compare?" just poped out in my head (no idea were I got this expression from). I can't find this expression a lot in the internet.

    So that's my question:
    Is this part correct or will I need to add the group thats compared in the same sentence? I think thats called "transitive verb". For example change it to: "'Group 1' How Do They Compare to 'group 2'?..."That just doesn't sound as "snappy" as my original idea. Is the original idea too colloquial?

    Further explanation of the topic (in case it's not clear engough):
    What I basically want to say: How do they perform? How do they do under treatment? Is their growth better/worse than in the control group?
    I hope its clear what I wanted to ask, thanks in advance!

    In case anyone needs german reference: "Wie schneiden sie ab?"/ "Wie ergeht es ihnen" is what I basically want to say
    Authorcapstan (1234309) 04 May 18, 08:39
    Comment
    related discussion: to measure up to so. - im Vergleich mit jmdm....
    related discussion: I don't measure up.
    related discussion: etwas gerecht werden - to measure up

    LEO:
    to stack up against so.- im Vergleich zu jmdm. dastehen [fig.]
    to stack up against sth. - im Vergleich zu etw. dastehen [fig.]

    _________________

    I'm not sure I followed your whole explanation (but thank you very much for trying to give so much context (-: ).

    But just on the face of it, I would say yes, 'How do they compare?' is a perfectly reasonable and idiomatic thing to say.

    You might also look at 'How do they measure up / stack up?'
    #1Author hm -- us (236141) 04 May 18, 08:44
    Comment
    Thanks for replying so fast.

    What would you need to know for better understanding what I want?

    Basically I have 2 questions:
    1) Is "How do they compare?" correct? Or do I need to say "How do they compare to group B" to get a linguisticaly correct expression?
    2) Is "How do they compare" to coloquial for an official piece of writing?
    3) Does it express what I want to say? Basically in the whole study we are comparing a special subgroup A to the larger group B, to know if their treatment response is as good as in group B
    4) measure up sounds good, too! Thanks! Would "How do they measure up?" be more appropriate?
    #2Authorcapstan (1234309) 04 May 18, 09:44
    Comment
    The expression is perfectly correct and idiomatic, but (a) I think you would usually mention both groups first (like this: ‘Lidl vs Aldi – how do they compare?’) and (b) I’m not sure it’s the best choice if the focus of your study is on Group 1 and Group 2 is merely a control group. I think it’s more typical of situations in which you are weighing up the relative merits of two different options.

    Would ‘how do they fare’ be a viable option?
    #3Author dulcinea (238640) 04 May 18, 10:00
     
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  
 
 
 
 
 ­ automatisch zu ­ ­ umgewandelt