Advertising - LEO without ads? LEO Pur
LEO

It looks like you’re using an ad blocker.

Would you like to support LEO?

Disable your ad blocker for LEO or make a donation.

 
  •  
  • Forum home

    Language lab

    well prepared or well-prepared?

    Topic

    well prepared or well-prepared?

    Comment

    which of these is correct (or correcterer)? Thanks! :



    a) With 6 Mars bars in their pockets as they set off, the boy scouts were well-prepared for any hunger attacks.


    b) With 6 Mars bars in their pockets as they set off, the boy scouts were well prepared for any hunger attacks.

    AuthorAnnaUK (806456) 02 Aug 22, 08:43
    Comment

    Collins meint:


    well-prepared; when postpositive: well prepared

    #1Author MiMo (236780) 02 Aug 22, 09:27
    Comment

    Link zu #1 https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/... (steht dort gleich oben zu BE)

    #2Author no me bré (700807) 02 Aug 22, 10:18
    Comment

    Ich habe es jetzt nachgelesen, aber ich gestehe, dass ich nicht wusste, was "postpositive" bedeutet. Ich fühle mich auch jetzt nicht firm genug, um eine Definition zu präsentieren.

    #3Author harambee (91833) 02 Aug 22, 10:43
    Comment

    “postpositive” : positioned / placed after the item modified:

     

    A well-prepared guide was waiting for them at the hotel.

    The guide waiting for them at the hotel was well prepared.

    #4AuthorBion (1092007) 02 Aug 22, 10:50
    Comment

    Normally, "postpositive" refers to things placed immediately after a noun, as in "He acted like a man eaten up by rage".

    Looks a bit funny here, as what they mean is just that it isn't in front of a noun.

    A well-prepared man = a man who was well prepared.

    #5Author CM2DD (236324) 02 Aug 22, 10:53
    Comment

    Verstehe ich das richtig, dass es im Satz im OP "well prepared" heißen muss, weil es auch da postpositive ist? Das hatte ich ohnehin vermutet, aber nach #1 war ich nicht mehr sicher.

    #6Author harambee (91833) 02 Aug 22, 11:01
    Comment

    According to that rule, yes.

    It's not universally applied, however. Many other dictionaries (e.g. Oxford) don't seem to care.

    #7Author CM2DD (236324) 02 Aug 22, 11:02
    Comment

    I would naturally write it without the hyphen, that is, instinctively following the postpositive rule (now that I have a name for it!)

    #8Author papousek (343122) 02 Aug 22, 12:40
    Comment

    As CM2DD points out "postpositive" strictly means occurring immediately after the noun (or pronoun).

     

    "predicative" describes the case where the adjective follows a verb, "attributive" where it precedes the noun:

     

    a well-prepared hiker (attributive)

    a hiker I thought well prepared (predicative)

    anyone well prepared (postpositive)

    #9AuthorBion (1092007) 02 Aug 22, 13:20
    Comment

    Good example, Bion! Couldn't think of a decent one.

    #10Author CM2DD (236324) 02 Aug 22, 13:29
     
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  
 
 
 
 
 ­ automatisch zu ­ ­ umgewandelt