Advertising - LEO without ads? LEO Pur
LEO

It looks like you’re using an ad blocker.

Would you like to support LEO?

Disable your ad blocker for LEO or make a donation.

 
  •  
  • Forum home

    English missing

    Vertrag mit SCHUTZWIRKUNG zu Gunsten Dritter

    Subject

    Vertrag mit SCHUTZWIRKUNG zu Gunsten Dritter

    Context/ examples
    Ist im deutschen Zivilrecht ein feststehender Ausdruck. This is a special German civil law term.
    Could anybody help? Thanks!
    Authordomlaw22 Feb 06, 20:56
    Suggestionprotective effect for third parties
    #1AuthorHelmi (U.S.)22 Feb 06, 21:10
    Suggestioncontract with protective consequences for third parties
    Sources
    Context/ examples
    The legal form of a contract with protective consequences for third parties (Vertrag mit Schutzwirkung für Dritte) is borrowed from German dogmatic scholarship, but may be interesting in this respect for an international audience as well.
    Comment
    A contract with protective consequences for (the benefit of) third parties.

    As used by H-B. Schäfer (jur. Wörterbuchautor) in the article above.
    #2AuthorMary (nz/a)22 Feb 06, 21:13
    Suggestionthird-party beneficiary contract
    Context/ examples
    If this is a contract where a provision works to the benefit of, or is enforceably by, a third party who did not sign the contract, the normal American legal expression would be "third-party beneficiary contract".
    #3AuthorRobert22 Feb 06, 21:28
    Suggestioncontract with protective consequences for third parties
    Comment
    Die Voraussetzungen sind / The conditions are:

    1) Anwendbarkeit / applicability
    There must be a contract between two parties ("first party" and "second party") whereby the wrongdoer (i.e. "first party") one of them is. The aggrieved party is the third party.

    2) Leistungsnähe / performance is closely related to the obligation
    The aggrieved party (i.e. the third party) is in close contact to the second party. Hence the third party nearly touches the obligations of the contract.

    3) Schutzpflicht / duty of protection from damage
    A duty of protection from damage means that there is a relationship with a special duty of care, e.g. parents-children or employer-employee or landlord-tenant. Another case is that the duty of protection is obvious, e.g. an audited annual accounts implies for a financial institution that the certified annual accounts are correct.

    4) Erkennbarkeit für den Schädiger / perceptibility to the wrongdoer
    The wrongdoer must be able to percept the possible aggrieved parties. E.g. a landlord knows that the tenant's relatives are possible victims of negligence (e.g. a defective staircase).

    5) Schutzbedürftigkeit / necessity of protection
    There is no necessity of protection, if the aggrieved party has own contractual causes of action. Claims resulting of tort are insufficient.

    Is that o.k.? Or just a nice try?
    #4Authordomlaw22 Feb 06, 23:51
    Comment
    Kommentar zu Roberts Beitrag:
    "third-party beneficiary contract" = "Vertrag zugunsten Dritter" (the original/explicit purport of the contract is to grant a benefit to a third person)
    this is totally different to
    "Vertrag mit Schutzwirkung zugunsten Dritter" (a third person comes to harm in the society of a contract of two different people)
    #5AuthorTAF14 Mar 07, 12:57
    Suggestionprefer "effect" to "consequences"
    Sources
    contract with protective effetc to third party
    Comment
    TAF is absolutely right. What Robert supposes is actually a Vertrag zugunsten Dritter and that is a different thing.
    #6Author Der Chef 2 (171212) 14 Mar 07, 13:17
    Comment
    Third the boss, as it were ;-) Robert is wrong and TAF is right.

    For posterity ...
    #7AuthorBacon [de] (264333) 14 Mar 07, 13:19
    Suggestion@Bacon
    Sources
    pretty late reaction this time mate...
    #8Author Der Chef 2 (171212) 14 Mar 07, 13:24
    Comment
    Oooh, sorry indeed. Pray pardon.

    ;-)
    #9AuthorBacon [de] (264333) 14 Mar 07, 13:25
     
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  
 
 
 
 
 ­ automatisch zu ­ ­ umgewandelt