Advertising - LEO without ads? LEO Pur
LEO

It looks like you’re using an ad blocker.

Would you like to support LEO?

Disable your ad blocker for LEO or make a donation.

 
  •  
  • Forum home

    German missing

    scholarship / stipend / grant / fellowship (what is the difference)

    Subject

    scholarship / stipend / grant / fellowship (what is the difference)

    Sources
    Index of Grants - The Fulbright Program expects of its grantees outstanding academic performance and an active contribution to the promotion of mutual understanding as "unofficial ambassadors" of their country. Scholars and students from all academic field are welcome to apply. http://www.fulbright.de/togermany/grants.html

    In October 2000, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation of Seattle, Washington, USA announced a donation to the University of Cambridge of $210 million to establish the Gates Cambridge Trust. This benefaction creates in perpetuity an international scholarship programme to enable outstanding graduate students from outside the United Kingdom to study at the University of Cambridge. http://www.gatesscholar.org/about/

    The Commonwealth Fund's Harkness Fellowships in Health Care Policy and Practice provide a unique opportunity for mid-career health services researchers and practitioners from Australia, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom to spend up to 12 months in the United States, conducting original research and working with leading U.S. health policy experts. http://www.commonwealthfund.org/fellowships/f...

    The School of Arts and Sciences also raised its minimum stipend for 10-month Ph.D. programs from $18,300 to $21,000, a 14.7 percent jump. (http://media.www.dailypennsylvanian.com/media...)
    Comment
    For the one German term "Stipendium" there are different English terms. I wonder what the difference between these terms is. I figured out that a fellowship is more about the membership in a group but does not necessarily involve a payment. But what is the difference between scholarship, grant and stipend? Is one more prestigious? Or are there other differences?
    AuthorChris19 Jul 08, 12:01
    Comment
    "Scholarship" and "stipend" are often used interchangeably -- although stipend actually refers to the amount of money that is granted by a scholarship. Example: "She received a scholarship. It carries a stipend of $10,000."

    Although Fulbright uses "grant" for their awards, scholarship would be -- it seems to me -- more appopriate since a scholarship is usually awarded for proven academic merit and excellence while a grant at least in the USA)is made on the basis of non-academic criteria (such as need, family income).

    Additionally, there are also "fellowships" which are actually scholarships for graduate students (i.e., students studying for an advanced degree such as a masters or doctorate).
    #1Authorzasius10 Aug 08, 22:52
    Suggestionsiehe unten
    Sources
    A "scholarship" is awarded to pay tuition or school related expenses and is based on merit: academic success, a history of service, athletic abilities, being a member of a minority... (the last one is controversial for some...). A scholarship can be applied for, or it might just be awarded by some other nomination process.

    A "stipend" is more like a fixed salary, often paid in one or a few lump sums, that can accompany a scholarship or fellowship, etc. A "stipend" can be compensation for being a teaching assistant or research assistant, or it might just be in addition to some scholarship and require no sort of labor on your part. Stipends cannot be applied for... they automatically come with something else.

    A "grant" is merely a sum of money awarded for some specific purpose, e.g. to conduct a research project, to write a book, to design educational materials, etc. Typically, all funds have a specified and pre-approved purpose such as purchasing necessary materials and equipment. The grant is not intended to pay your personal expenses. But some portion of the grant may be set aside to compensate those working on the project, as people, of course, have to get paid for their labor! But that would have been approved in an application process. These grants are always applied for and have very elaborate and often complex application requirements... very tedious!

    [But a "grant" can also take on another meaning in a different context: A "grant" can also be a "need-based" scholarship intended for tuition or related expenses, as opposed to a "merit-based" scholarship. Need-base merely means that you and your parents cannot afford to pay tuition and/or related expenses. For some reason, these are called "grants". There is a federal application to apply for such grants. If you meet the rquirements, you are automatically awarded grants by your university and the government.]

    A "fellowship" means that you awarded some combination of a stipend, a grant or scholarship for a set amount of time and entails that you are a member of some elite group. Some PhD students, for example, receive prestigious "dissertation fellowships" to complete their dissertations. You would receive a scholarship for all tuition and a stipend to pay your cost of living. Likewise, a professor might receive a "faculty release fellowship" to complete a book or article, and would likewise receive some stipend to pay for living costs. The basic idea is that due to the promise of you research, you are supported financially for a set amount of time so that you can work exclusively on that project. Sometimes you are required to conduct your research at a particular institution (archive, library, lab) and sometimes you are even required to live in a house with the other "fellows"... a "research community". Almost always, you have obligations such as giving updates and presenting the research you completed during the time frame. Fellowships are applied for.

    One thing you forgot, that is actually part of Fullbright and in American academia in general, are the "Assistantships": like a fellowship in that you are awarded a scholarship and a stipend, but you have to perform some duty, such as assisting a professor in the classroom or with a research project, teaching a class yourself, conducting your own research, editing or assitisting in editing a journal, etc. Assistants are graduate student (and a some universities undergraduate) employees. Assistantships are not applied for directly (except programs like Fullbright); typically you applye to enter a MA or PhD program, and if you are accepted in the program, you are eligible for an assistantship, but this does not guarantee you will get one, because they are always limited.
    #2AuthorTacitus04 Jan 10, 11:21
    Comment
    For me, there are too many may’s and might’s.
    What’s the basic difference that makes a native speaker say “research stipend” instead of “research fellowship” or “research scholarship”?
    What do you imply when you say “She’s won a fellowship” instead of “She’s won a scholarship”?
     
    Is studentship strictly BE and scholarship and fellowship strictly AE?
    Are bursary and student grant identical?
    #3Author Alivo (1159675) 24 May 18, 23:18
    Comment
    Tacitus has really explained it all very well, so I'll quote the relevant passages from his post and add some information of my own:
     
    1. What’s the basic difference that makes a native speaker say “research stipend” instead of “research fellowship” or “research scholarship”?
     
    A "stipend" is more like a fixed salary, often paid in one or a few lump sums, that can accompany a scholarship or fellowship, etc... Stipends cannot be applied for... they automatically come with something else. It can be used for expenses other than tuition/fees.
     
    A "scholarship" is awarded to pay tuition or school related expenses, i.e. it is earmarked for a particular purpose. Indeed it may not even be paid directly to the student, instead going straight to the university. A scholarship may have various obligations, such as maintaining a particular GPA, or a number of years of military service post-graduation (military scholarships), or sporting performance (sports scholarships), etc.
     
    A "fellowship" means that you awarded some combination of a stipend, a grant or scholarship for a set amount of time and entails that you are a member of some elite group... The basic idea is that due to the promise of your research, you are supported financially for a set amount of time so that you can work exclusively on that project... Almost always, you have obligations such as giving updates and presenting the research you completed during the time frame.
     

    2. Is studentship strictly BE and scholarship and fellowship strictly AE?

    No, the words scholarship and fellowship are used in both varieties of English.
     

    3. Are bursary and student grant identical?

    Bursary is exclusively BE. In general, a bursary or student grant is money awarded on the basis of need, i.e. financial hardship. In the UK, bursaries are awarded at both school and university level. I don't know whether this is the case with student grants.
    #4Author covellite (520987) 25 May 18, 10:57
    Comment
    I see. If a fellowship is awarded to a member of some elite group, it cannot be for ordinary students, it's probably only for graduates and a scholarship is for students.
    #5Author Alivo (1159675) 26 May 18, 02:01
     
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  
 
 
 
 
 ­ automatisch zu ­ ­ umgewandelt